Please note that it's often best to let children lead the conversation, as most kids naturally start questioning the Santa myth by now.
Therefore, telling them when they ask or show doubt preserves trust better than a sudden reveal. If they're asking, answer honestly by framing Santa as a symbol of giving, linking it to St. Nicholas, and involving them in the "magic" for younger kids.
Saint Nicolas, Kris Kringle, Father Christmas, or Santa Claus, the legendary figure was known for bringing gifts to good children on Christmas Eve, traveling in his sleigh with the help of Rudolph, his red-nosed reindeer.
A beautiful passage from one of the most famous editorials in American journalism - Church's "Yes, Virginia, There is a Santa Claus," published in the New York Sun in 1897. It was written in response to eight-year-old’s letter asking whether Santa Claus really existed.
What makes this editorial enduring is how Church transformed a child's simple question into a meditation on faith, imagination, and the intangible things that give life meaning. He wasn't really arguing for the literal existence of Santa Claus, but rather defending the value of wonder, generosity, and the unseen dimensions of human experience - love, devotion, poetry, romance - that can't be measured or proved but are nonetheless profoundly real.
The passage suggests that some truths transcend empirical verification. Just as we can't see love or measure poetry in a laboratory, yet they're undeniably real in their effects on our lives, Santa represents something genuine: the spirit of giving, the magic of childhood wonder, and our capacity for belief in goodness.
It's a particularly poignant message during the holiday season, reminding us that not everything meaningful can be reduced to what we can physically observe or rationally prove. Sometimes the most important things are those we choose to believe in because they make the world more beautiful.
-
Children asking questions:
If they're probing about inconsistencies or bringing up friends' opinions, they're ready for the truth.
-
They're using logic:
A 14-year-old's critical thinking skills are strong; they're more likely to piece it together.
How to approach the conversation:
-
Let them lead:
Ask them what they think or have heard.
-
Frame it as a symbol:
Explain that Santa represents the spirit of giving, generosity, and kindness, based on the real St. Nicholas.
-
Involve them in the "magic":
Turn it into a shared secret where they can help with traditions for younger siblings or family, a perk for "figuring it out".
-
Focus on family values:
Shift the focus from the myth to the true meaning of Christmas, such as family, giving, and doing good deeds.
Why not just tell them?
-
Avoids later disappointment:
Finding out abruptly from peers can be more jarring than a gentle family conversation.
-
Maintains trust:
Being honest when they ask preserves the parent-child bond, as some experts worry the myth can undermine trust if discovered late
Santa Claus dates back to about 280 A.D., when St. Nicholas was reportedly born.
This would make Santa approximately 1,744 years old today.
