The CMA Owes Country Music Fans an Explanation The Country Music Ass should be embarrassed by its failure to properly recognize two influential figures in country music: Raul Malo and David Allan Coe.
Malo, the Cuban-American frontman of The Mavericks, possessed a voice that was nothing short of extraordinary. He was arguably one of the greatest vocalists ever to grace country music, in the company of legends such as George Jones. The Mavericks won the CMA's Vocal Group of the Year award in both 1995 and 1996. His passing on December 8 deserved more than a passing mention. He deserved a proper tribute, alongside the recognition afforded Dolly Parton, John Anderson and Richard Sterban.
Then there is David Allan Coe, whose exclusion is particularly difficult to understand.
Coe was a singular figure in country music. To a substantial contingent of country fans, he belongs among the genre's most influential performers and songwriters. His own chart success never fully reflected his influence, but his songwriting produced major hits for other artists, including Johnny PayCheck and Tanya Tucker.
His legacy is complicated, and his controversies are part of the public record. But recognizing a musician's contribution to country music does not require endorsing every aspect of his life or career.
The CMA's In Memoriam segment is an opportunity to remember the people who helped shape the music, its history and its audience. It should not become a popularity contest or a selective exercise in remembrance.
Country music deserves an inclusive history. Its fans deserve an inclusive tribute.
Leaving Raul Malo and David Allan Coe out of that conversation raises a legitimate question: Who decides whose contributions are worthy of being remembered?