The Best Small Cities, and or neighborhoods in America can be defined as Where Quality of Life Meets basic Affordability
As more Americans re-evaluate what “the good life” really means, many are setting their sights away from crowded urban centers or remote rural settings. According to recent research, nearly half of Americans (47%) say the suburbs are their ideal place to live—compared to just 24% preferring urban life and 23% favoring rural areas. And nestled between these broad categories lies a sweet spot: small cities.
Small cities offer the perfect blend of affordability, safety, and quality of life. They're large enough to provide access to jobs, schools, healthcare, and entertainment—yet small enough to avoid the congestion, cost, and stress of a big city.
A recent comprehensive study analyzed 1,318 communities across the U.S. with populations under 100,000 to find the best small cities in America. The research focused strictly on the "city proper" (excluding surrounding metro areas) and measured performance across five major categories:
- Affordability
- Economic Health
- Education & Health
- Quality of Life
- Safety
Each city was evaluated using 45 different metrics, with scores assigned on a 100-point scale—higher scores reflected better living conditions.
Living in a small city can drastically cut down your cost of living, especially compared to major urban centers. But the best small cities go beyond affordability. They feature:
- Robust job markets
- High-performing schools
- Top-tier healthcare
- Safe neighborhoods
- Unique community character
While they may lack the extensive public transportation systems of large cities, they often make up for it with shorter commutes, less congestion, and a strong sense of local identity.
The Top Four
After analyzing hundreds of locations, the study identified four standout small cities that lead the pack:
1. Carmel, Indiana
Claiming the #1 spot, Carmel boasts strong household incomes, low unemployment, and exceptionally safe streets. This well-planned city combines Midwestern charm with urban-style amenities, making it a standout for families and professionals alike.
2. Brookfield, Wisconsin
Just outside of Milwaukee, Brookfield offers the perks of a small-town lifestyle with the benefit of nearby city access. With top schools and a thriving local economy, it’s an ideal place for stability and long-term growth.
3. Apex, North Carolina
Nicknamed "The Peak of Good Living," Apex blends historic charm with modern suburban development. It's part of the fast-growing Research Triangle area, offering access to tech jobs, great schools, and a high quality of life.
4. City Island, New York
A hidden gem tucked within the Bronx, City Island feels like a quaint seaside village—right inside New York City. Known for its nautical vibe, fresh seafood, and tight-knit community, it offers a rare blend of small-town charm and urban proximity.
If you're thinking about relocating, small cities offer a compelling alternative to both sprawling metros and remote countryside. Whether you're drawn by affordability, safety, or simply a better work-life balance, the best small cities in America are proving that bigger isn’t always better.
From Carmel’s polished suburban charm to City Island’s unexpected slice of paradise, these small cities are showing Americans what it truly means to live well.