New York After 9/11: The City Survived. Our Lives Changed Forever.
I woke up on the morning of Sept. 11, 2001, expecting another beautiful early-fall day in New York City.
Instead, I found myself in the midst of the most horrific news story of my professional career.
At the time, I was the Associated Press Television News bureau chief in New York. APTN had hundreds of clients around the world, and when the first commercial airliner struck the World Trade Center, followed by the second, the ordinary responsibilities of a newsroom instantly became something else entirely.
Our clients needed information, pictures, video, reporters and answers. They needed us to be everywhere. We worked essentially nonstop.
But while I was trying to help the world understand what was happening in New York, my own world had suddenly become frighteningly uncertain.
For hours, I could not reach my girlfriend and partner, Ms. Y. I did not know where she was or whether she was safe.
And at the same time, another extraordinary story was unfolding in my personal life.
Only days earlier, a City Island neighbor, Mr. S., had invited me to his home for a Sunday barbecue. His son was visiting from Switzerland and, as young people sometimes do, was bored and looking for something to do.
When he asked whether anything was happening nearby, I told him about a live concert at Orchard Beach. I took him there and gave him two backstage passes, one for him and one for the first young woman he liked. Then I left him with a possible plan.
The following day, his father was frantic. His son had not come home.
He blamed me for his disappearance and said he was going to call the NYPD. He told me he would not go to work until he knew his son was safe.
I tried to reassure him that his son had probably met someone and simply spent the night with her.
He eventually learned that was essentially what had happened. The young man had gotten lucky, spending Sunday and Monday nights with a new friend with benefits.
He thanked me.
Then came Tuesday.
His father was an engineer whose office was in the World Trade Center.
And on Tuesday morning, Sept. 11, he refused to go to work.
That detail would forever stay with me.
The son had stayed out because of a concert. The father stayed home because he was worried about his son. And a few hours later, the World Trade Center was gone.
There are moments in history when the difference between life and death can come down to something impossibly small: a decision, a delay, a missed train, a telephone call, a young man who refuses to go home, a new friend who says, “Let’s go to the concert.”
We usually call such things coincidence.
After Sept. 11, I stopped being quite so certain.
And then there was the woman arriving from Shanghai.
While I was desperately trying to find my partner, who turned out to be safe, thank God, a commercial airliner carrying a woman and her child was flying toward the United States. The attacks closed American airspace, and their flight was forced to make an unscheduled landing in Vancouver.
I did not know it then, but this woman, Ms. C., would become extraordinarily important to me.
She is a marvelous musician, and that is how we met. She is a wonderful woman and, among many other things, I eventually learned she is a great kisser.
I fell for her head over heels.
Eventually, I asked her to marry me.
That is one of the strangest things about Sept. 11 when I remember it now. The day was filled with death, destruction, fear and uncertainty. Yet amid all that darkness, life was also making decisions of its own.
People met. People were separated. People survived. Others did not.
And somewhere amid all of it, two people fell in love.
Some people who otherwise might have been working inside the World Trade Center that morning simply were not there.
For me, Sept. 11 was not only an enormous national tragedy or the biggest story I had ever covered. It became a deeply personal lesson in how fragile the architecture of ordinary life really is.
That morning, I was a journalist responsible for helping thousands of people understand history as it happened.
But I was also a man trying to find the people I loved.
And somewhere in that terrible day was a lesson I have never forgotten:
Sometimes we survive history because of decisions we make before we know history is coming.
The professional obligation to gather news about what was happening collided with the most primitive human instinct: finding someone you love and knowing they are alive.
Ms. Y. was safe, but she later told me that her job required her to return to Asia.
That is another part of the story of Sept. 11 that statistics cannot capture.
History is often remembered through presidents, wars, buildings and casualty figures. But history also enters ordinary lives without knocking. It separates people. It changes plans. It creates unlikely encounters. Sometimes, in the middle of unimaginable tragedy, it alters the course of two people's lives forever.
Twenty-five years later, Ms. C. and I are married, and New York itself tells a similar story.
The skyline has been rebuilt. Lower Manhattan was transformed into a center of commerce, tourism, culture and luxury housing. Former industrial waterfronts are now coveted residential neighborhoods. Technology, finance, tourism and global investment have helped make New York an even more powerful international city.
Our city survived.
But survival and transformation are not the same thing.
Some of the city's successes since 9/11 have carried consequences. Rising property values and redevelopment have brought prosperity to some neighborhoods while making others increasingly unaffordable. Longtime residents have watched familiar communities change. Working- and middle-class residents have been squeezed by housing costs while wealth has become increasingly concentrated.
The changes reached beyond bricks, mortar and money.
Sept. 11 permanently altered New York's relationship with security, surveillance and policing. Immigrants and Muslim New Yorkers experienced a city and country increasingly shaped by suspicion and national-security concerns. Airports, subways, skyscrapers and public gatherings acquired a new psychological dimension.
Yet New Yorkers did what New York has always done.
We kept moving.
Life goes on.
People returned to work. Restaurants reopened. Children went back to school. Immigrants kept arriving. Artists continued creating. The subway kept running. The city eventually laughed again.
That resilience became part of New York's mythology.
But resilience should never become an excuse for forgetting what was lost.
The New York of 2026 is wealthier and dramatically transformed from the city I knew on that terrible September morning. It is also more expensive, more unequal and, in many ways, less recognizable.
Twenty-five years after the towers fell, the question is no longer whether New York survived.
It did.
The more difficult question is what kind of New York we built from the ruins, and who else gets to call it home.
Because 9/11 changed New York.
It also changed millions of individual lives, including ours.
At Ground Zero, surrounded by destruction I still struggle to describe, I ran into an old colleague, Mr. C., who was there reporting for his employer.
By then, the emotional weight of everything I had seen and experienced was beginning to overwhelm me.
He looked at me and asked, “Are you OK? What's wrong?”
I tried to brush it off.
“Nothing,” I told him. “I just got something stuck under my eyelid.”
He knew me.
I suspect he knew better.
But that was how some of us survived that day.
There was no time to stop. No time to fully absorb what we were witnessing. No time to break down, even when tears were fighting to get out.
There was always another assignment, another call, another client somewhere in the world waiting for information, pictures and answers.
So I kept working.
Like so many journalists, police officers, firefighters, emergency workers and ordinary New Yorkers, we pushed forward because stopping meant confronting the full horror of what had happened.
And sometimes, when someone asked whether you were all right, the only answer you could manage was that something was stuck in your eye.
Twenty-five years later, I understand something I could not have understood that morning.
History can destroy the world we know in a matter of hours.
It can separate people, change the course of lives and leave a city permanently transformed.
But it cannot stop life from moving forward.
New York survived.
As New Yorkers and Americans we We pushed on rebuilt and survived. And somehow, against all odds, life went on. Two days after the September 11 attacks, the FAA lifted the nationwide ground stop that had emptied U.S. airspace. Civilian flights began returning to the schedules that had been frozen since Tuesday morning.
RFES
If anyone is wondering what UB is up to, or how to find me. This Blog changes that. Imaginus.biz at gmail.com